Skip to Content

Apple Pie Cocktail

Move over pumpkin cockatils, this Apple Pie Cocktail is going to become the new favorite fall cocktail recipe! With warm spices from the cinnamon whiskey and the Spiced Apple Cider, this drink tastes like liquid apple pie. Each sip will warm you up from the inside out, perfect for the chilly fall evening.

If you’re all about the fall flavored drinks and treats, we have a ton of tasty ones for you. We totally recommend making an Apple Pie Drink to sip on while you enjoy your very own individual sized Apple Crisp dessert. Or, maybe you need a morning drink with your Apple Pie Overnight Oats! We aren’t judging, whatever floats your boat.

If you love Apple Drinks, then you MUST try this Apple Cider Sangria– it’s another fantastic apple fall drink.

The post may contain affiliate links. Read my full disclosure policy here.

Jar of Apple Pie Cocktail with apples around it.

🍎 Why You’ll Love this Cocktail

  • ready in just a few minutes
  • tastes just like a slice of apple pie
  • great for fall festivals, apple picking, pumpkin patch visits, and while the kids go trick-or-treating
  • perfect for a fall party or to enjoy during the winter months

🍻 Ingredients Needed

Get more info on these ingredients, like quantities, in the recipe card below.

  • Vanilla Vodka
  • Fireball Whiskey
  • Spiced Apple Cider
  • Simple Syrup, for rim
  • Brown Sugar, for rim
  • Garnish: Cinnamon Sugar, Apple Slice, Cinnamon Stick
Apple Pie Drink with ingredients around it.

Helpful Tools Needed

Cocktail Shaker with Jigger or Shot Glass

Sale
24oz Cocktail Shaker Bar Set - Professional Margarita Mixer Drink Shaker and Measuring Jigger & Mixing Spoon Set - Professional Stainless Steel Bar Tools Built-in Bartender Strainer for Martini Kit
  • Begin your career as a hobby mixologist with this cocktail shaker: Works like a charm and doesn't leak, this cocktail shaker set includes: shaker cup (24 oz/750ml), airtight lid, built-in strainer, two-sided measuring jigger (1.0 oz & 0.5 oz) and an elegant bar spoon. This martini shaker will help you create the best cocktails, martini and new drink recipes.

Measuring Cups

Sale
Simply Gourmet Measuring Cups and Spoons Set of 12 Stainless Steel for Cooking & Baking
  • Dishwasher safe: Designed with high-quality stainless steel these dishwasher safe measuring cups and spoons are built to last a lifetime.

Shallow Bowl

Small Bowls - Ice Cream Dessert Bowl 8.5 oz - Ceramic Bowl Set of 6 - Colorful Shallow Bowl for Side Dish | Snack | Appetizer - Microwave and Dishwasher Safe - 5.5 x 1.3 Inches
  • 【Quality & Healthy】 This bowls set is made of high-quality ceramic which is pretty rugged, lead free, no harmful substance. They are made as perfect bowls for everyday use

Spoon for Stirring

Iced Tea Spoons, Kyraton Stainless Steel 7.5" Long Handle Mixing Spoon, Coffee Spoon, Stirring Bar Spoon, Cocktail Spoon, Latte Spoon Pack of 6
  • Iced Tea Spoon Set of 6 pieces 7.5 inches stainless steel Iced tea spoon, heavy duty and durable. Great for daily use, hotel, restaurant, special events.

Mason Jar for Storing and Serving

Wide Mouth Mason Jars 16 oz [5 Pack] With mason jar lids and Bands, mason jars 16 oz - For Canning, Fermenting, Pickling - Jar Décor - Microwave/Freeze/Dishwasher Safe + SEWANTA Jar Opener
  • 5 PACK CANNING JARS - 16 ounce jars perfect for canning, pickling, preserving, and fermenting fruits and veggies that can be canned and sealed for up to 18 Months. Embossed measurement markings for precise filling. Label line for writing dates and identifying contents.

How to Make An Apple Pie Cocktail

  1. Add enough simple syrup into a small shallow dish to wet the rim of your mason jar.
  2. Add 2-3 tablespoons of brown sugar in a separate shallow dish. 
  3. Dip the rim of your mason jar into the simple syrup and then roll the edge into brown sugar to coat the rim.
  4. Fill your mason jar with ice.
  5. Add 1 shot of Vanilla Vodka
  6. Add 1 shot of Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey.
  7. Add 5 ounces of Spiced Apple Cider and stir.
  8. Add a sprinkle of Cinnamon Sugar on top.
  9. Garnish with an apple slice and cinnamon stick. Serve and enjoy.
How to make apple pie cocktail collage of images.
Rest of the How to make apple pie cocktail collage of images.

Variations

Use a cocktail shaker. Instead of mixing everything directly in your mason jar, you can mix this cocktail in a cocktail shaker. Then, make your brown sugar rim around the mason jar with the simple syrup and brown sugar before pouring the delicious fall cocktail.

Make a hot apple pie cocktail. Warm up your apple cider before mixing your drink. I also suggest ditching the ice cubes to keep this a nice hot drink. In this case, you could also serve this cocktail in coffee mugs instead of mason jars. You could also mix everything together and warm in over medium-high heat in a small saucepan for just a short period of time to make a great drink.

Trade spirits. Instead of Fireball whisky, you can use any cinnamon whisky that you have and prefer. If you don’t like vanilla vodka, you can use another fall flavored vodka. You can also use regular vodka with vanilla extract if in a pinch.

Add Apple Crisp Syrup. If you really want even more apple, you can add some Apple Crisp Syrup, or trade it out for some of the spices that you planned on using.

Tips

  • Depending on the kind and size of mason jar you use, it can be difficult to get the brown sugar to stick to the rim. In this case, use some Corn Syrup or Honey as an alternative to simple syrup.
  • If you don’t have cinnamon sticks, you can add ground cinnamon.
  • If you don’t want to use a mason jar, you can use any cocktail glass.
Ingredients needed to make the jar of apple pie drink.

Can You Make A Big Batch?

Yes, this recipe is easy to scale to make more fall cocktails! If you wish, you can make a larger batch of this in a pitcher and then serve them from the pitcher and pour into individual glasses or jars.

Can I Make These Ahead of Time?

Yes, you can. The only thing we suggest doing is making this and storing it in a pitcher in the refrigerator until you’re ready to serve them. Do NOT add the ice to the pitcher, simply add ice to jars when you want to serve. You can make this drink a few hours in advance.

Storage

Since you can make larger batches of this ahead of time, you can store smaller jars of this as well. If you plan on storing, do not add the ice to the drinks or you’ll end up with watered down Apple Pie Cocktails.

I only suggest storing this drink for a few hours.

More Easy Cocktails

More Fall Apple Recipes

Close up of an apple pie drink in a jar.

Apple Pie Cocktail

Mason Jar Recipe
Make this super easy Apple Pie Cocktail in just a few minutes with a few ingredients. It's like drinking a slice of apple pie!
Prep Time 5 mins
Total Time 5 mins
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Servings 1 serving

Ingredients
  

  • 1.5 oz Vanilla Vodka
  • 1.5 oz Fireball Whiskey
  • 5 oz Spiced Apple Cider
  • Simple Syrup for rim
  • Brown Sugar for rim
  • Garnish: Cinnamon Sugar Apple Slice, Cinnamon Stick

Instructions
 

  • Add enough simple syrup into a small shallow dish to wet the rim of your mason jar.
  • Add 2-3 tablespoons of brown sugar in a separate shallow dish.
  • Dip the rim of your mason jar into the simple syrup and then roll the edge into brown sugar to coat the rim.
  • Fill your mason jar with ice.
  • Add 1 shot of Vanilla Vodka
  • Add 1 shot of Fireball Cinnamon Whiskey.
  • Add 5 ounces of Spiced Apple Cider and stir.
  • Add a sprinkle of Cinnamon Sugar on top.
  • Garnish with an apple slice and cinnamon stick. Serve and enjoy.
Keyword Apple Pie Cocktail
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Make sure to follow us on Instagram and Pinterest to keep up with all our new recipes. Tag us if you make the recipe on IG or share your thoughts by commenting on the pin on Pinterest.

Keep On Sippin’ On Something Sweet

Pin It For Later

Apple Pie Cocktail in a jar with text overlay.

Sharing is caring!

Recipe Rating