Skip to Content

Creepy Halloween Eyeball Drink (Kid-Friendly Party Punch)

Everyone loves a good eyeball drink! This Halloween eyeball punch is the perfect kid-friendly party punch that will have everyone taking a second look. Don’t let the eyeballs fool you – this punch is full of yummy flavor!

What we love about this kid’s Halloween party drink is that it’s perfect for a spooky delicious time. They can fill their cup, get creeped out, and then come back for more!

Forget about the overpriced drink recipes and make your own party punch easily at home. Serve up a Spooky Adults Only Halloween Jungle Juice to have drinks covered for everybody at your Halloween party! You could also make this fun 3 ingredient Green Halloween Cocktail.

We are loving the Halloween cocktails and Halloween drinks this spooky season!

The post may contain affiliate links. Read my full disclosure policy here.

Don’t miss out on the best Witches Brew (Halloween punch recipe)!

Looking down on a candy eyeball drink for Halloween.

Why You’ll Love This Eyeball Punch Recipe

  • It’s a simple Halloween party punch recipe that’s perfect for Halloween
  • There are only 6 simple ingredients needed
  • You can use this for a Halloween party, class party, or anything else that you can think of!

Ingredients

Here is everything that you’ll need to make this Spooky Halloween Punch.

  • Orange Fanta
  • Cherry juice
  • Lemon juice
  • Ice
  • Jelly eyes
  • Red fruit gel color
Ingredients needed to make Halloween Eyeball Party Punch.

Tools Needed

Measuring cups and spoons 

Morgenhaan 13-Piece Lifetime Measuring Cups & Spoons Set with Forever Handles
  • Made with a specialty-grade 0.8 millimetre thick stainless steel

Whisk

Sale
Whisks for Cooking, 3 Pack Stainless Steel Whisk for Blending, Whisking, Beating and Stirring, Enhanced Version Balloon Wire Whisk Set, 8"+10"+12"
  • [Reinforced Metal Whisk]:12 inches of food-grade stainless steel whisk adopted bold 8 wire processing, which solves the pain of bending or the line breaking of some common whisks for cooking on the market during some heavy mixing and stirring.The wires do not get tangled in each other and the spacing helps wire whisk liquids better.

Mason Jars for Serving

Wide Mouth Mason Jars 16 oz [5 Pack] With mason jar lids and Bands, mason jars 16 oz - For Canning, Fermenting, Pickling - Jar Décor - Microwave/Freeze/Dishwasher Safe + SEWANTA Jar Opener
  • 5 PACK CANNING JARS - 16 ounce jars perfect for canning, pickling, preserving, and fermenting fruits and veggies that can be canned and sealed for up to 18 Months. Embossed measurement markings for precise filling. Label line for writing dates and identifying contents.

How To Make Halloween Eyeball Punch

You’re going to love the ease of this simple punch recipe! It proves that making a fun recipe doesn’t have to be hard to do at all!

  1. Combine the Fanta soda with the cherry juice in a bowl.
  2. Squeeze in the lemon juice.
  3. Decorate the glass with some red food coloring, and add ice and the eyeballs.
  4. Pour in the punch, and make sure to add a straw with an eyeball on it!
Jar of Halloween drink with floating candy eyeballs.

Can what else can I use besides the red gel food coloring?

If you don’t have the food coloring, anything red and sweet will work with this great drink. You can add jello or even add some whipped cream that you dye red with Kool-Aid powder!

Helpful Tips 

  • The biggest thing to remember when making this punch recipe is that you don’t want to add ice to the punch bowl. This will make it watered down and cause the flavor to not be as strong.
  • Add the ice to everyone’s individual cups so that it stays fresh and delicious.
  • If you can’t find the candy eyeballs in the grocery store, you can use lychee eyeballs.
  • Don’t forget to put your straw through your candy eyeball for a real spooky effect. If you don’t want to use your straw, you can use cocktail sticks or bamboo skewers.
  • You can ditch the individual drinks and make a large punch bowl of this drink for your Halloween celebration.
  • For a spooky effect, serve over dry ice with your bloody eyeballs to really get in the spooky spirit of the holiday.
Red spooky Halloween drink in a jar.

Recipe Variations 

Looking for a few easy variations? Here are some ideas to try!

Change the soda – Is there a different red soda that you like? Give it a try!

Use another jelly body part – I’ve seen fingers that would be fun to add!

Wanting to make the punch a bit more citrus-flavored? You can easily add a little bit of Sprite to the mixture!

Don’t like fanta? If you don’t like Fanta Orange soda, you can use orange juice instead.

Swap out juices- You can use other juices that you like, like cranberry juice, lime juice, lemon juice, grapefruit juice, etc. You can also use lemon lime soda, ginger ale, etc.

Turn these into spooky cocktails- Make this an adults only 21+ years and older cocktail by adding some vodka or spiced rum. Either would be the perfect addition. If you like the fruity flavors, add some peach schnapps for another tasty flavor.

Jar of Halloween red party punch.

FAQ

Can I make this Halloween punch in advance?

Yes, you can! Just add the ingredients into a punch bowl and store it in the fridge. When you’re ready to serve, just stir it first.

Can you freeze this punch?

If you want to freeze some of this punch recipe, pour it into ice cube trays and put it into the freezer. You can then pop them out and use them as “ice cubes” in your drink and not have to worry about it watering your punch recipe down.

What type of glasses do you serve this punch in?

We like serving it in mason jars, of course! The wide mouth makes it perfect for pouring in and drinking out of without making a mess.

You can also serve these in martini glasses, regular cocktail glasses, high ballers, etc and feel free to serve in a glass pitcher or something else.

Jar of Halloween party punch.

Storage

I think that this punch recipe is best served right when you make it. If you need to store it, cover it and keep it chilled in the fridge.

We don’t recommend trying to keep this Halloween eyeball drink longer than the day you make it. Everything is best when you first make it, especially if you add ice. You don’t want a watered down drink!

Other Drink Recipes 

If you’re a fan of making drink recipes, here are some others that we think you’ll like!

Jar of red punch.

Creepy Halloween Eyeball Drink (Kid-Friendly Party Punch)

Mason Jar Recipe
This fun Eyeball party punch for kids is a spooky drink that is spooky good! Perfect for a Halloween party!
Prep Time 5 mins
Total Time 5 mins
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Servings 1 servings

Ingredients
  

  • 1 cup Orange Fanta
  • 1 cup cherry juice
  • 2 tbsp lemon juice
  • 1 cup ice
  • 4-6 Jelly eyeballs
  • Red fruit gel coloring

Instructions
 

  • Combine the Fanta soda with the cherry juice in a bowl.
  • Squeeze in the lemon juice.
  • Decorate the glass with some red food coloring, and add ice and the eyeballs.
  • Pour in the punch, and make sure to add a straw with an eyeball on it!
Keyword eyeball drink
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Make sure to follow us on Instagram and Pinterest to keep up with all our new recipes. Tag us if you make the recipe on IG or share your thoughts by commenting on the pin on Pinterest.

Keep On Sippin’ On Something Sweet

Pin It For Later

A jar of red drink with candy eyeball in straw and text overlay.

Sharing is caring!

Recipe Rating