Skip to Content

Easy Witches Brew Punch Recipe

Easy Witches Brew Punch Recipe

Let’s come together, hover over our cauldron, and make Witches Brew Punch this Halloween. It is kid-friendly and super simple to make. 

We love Halloween, and one of the things you can guarantee gets the whole family excited in a fun way is themed food and drink. You just can’t beat it! This kid-friendly witches brew is the perfect spooky Halloween punch to enjoy together. Some might even describe it as tasting like liquid candy. Ideal for Halloween parties and you can even make it “adults only” with a tweak here and there. 

If you haven’t already tried it, this green Halloween cocktail is perfect for your Halloween party! This one isn’t kid-friendly and certainly packs a punch. 

The post may contain affiliate links. Read my full disclosure policy here.

Three jars of ice and witches brew with a cauldron with dry ice.

❤️ Why You’ll Love This Witches Brew Punch Recipe

  • Something you can make with the kids and is an easy recipe
  • Simple to make an adults-only version
  • Delicious fruity flavor
  • A festive drink to wow your party guests.

🎃 Ingredients Needed

Get more info on these simple ingredients in the recipe card below.

  • Blue raspberry gelatin
  • Granulated sugar
  • Boiling water
  • Pineapple juice
  • Ginger ale or lemon-lime soda drink
Ingredients needed for Witches Brew Drink.

🍹 Helpful Tools

Pitcher 

Wooden spoon

Sale
KitchenAid Universal Bamboo Tools, 12-Inch
  • ESSENTIAL TOOL: great for basting roasts, spooning out sauces and jus, and stirring soups, sauces, and stews

Tea kettle or large stock pot

Tea Kettle, 2.7 Quart / 3 Liter BELANKO Stainless Steel Tea Kettles for Stove Top, Food Grade Teapot with Wood Pattern Handle Loud Whistling for Coffee, Milk etc, Gas Electric Applicable - Black
  • [ Food-Grade Material & New Design ] BELANKO tea kettle uses professional food-grade materials and 18/8 stainless steel craftsmanship to ensure that it is rust & corrosion resistant and heats up quickly. Every surface exposed to water and food particles is certified as food grade and easy to clean. Also, we have designed a new diamond appearance, which makes your tea pot more unique.
Cooks Standard Professional Stainless Steel Stockpot, 11 Quart, Silver
  • Made with Brushed 18/10 stainless steel inside and out with an aluminum disc layered in the bottom

Cauldron or large punch bowl

Sale
Halloween Cauldron Plastic Large 7" Black Witch Cauldron Decor Prop, Trick or Treat Bucket, Witch Costume Accessory by 4E's Novelty
  • DURABLE PLASTIC CAULDRON - Large size 7" wide. Updated design: No hole on the bottom. Made of premium material, Durable & Strong enough to hold candy. The jet black cauldron has two faux handles molded into the design.
Premium Quality Plastic Punch Bowl With Ladle - Large 2 Gallon Bowl With 5 oz Ladle by Upper Midland Products
  • SUPER STRONG THICK PLASTIC WITH A CRYSTAL LOOK - This punch bowl has a pretty glass look to it. It is heavy duty plastic, and it is lightweight.

Mason Jars for Serving

Ball Regular Mouth Mason Jars 16 oz. (12 Pack) - Pint Size Jars with Airtight Lids and Bands for Canning, Fermenting, Pickling, or DIY Decors and Projects - Bundled with Peaknip Jar Opener
  • THE PERFECT CANNING JARS - Ball Mason Jars come with airtight lids and bands that allow you to store your homemade preserves for up to 18 months. They make the perfect container for preserving high-acid foods like salsas and pickles, as well as low-acid foods like meats and more!

How To Make The Witches Brew Punch 

You are only a few short steps away from creating this non-alcoholic witch’s brew.

  1. Get your large stock pot and boil 2 cups of water. Or you could use your tea kettle for this. 
  2. Next up, get a pitcher and add the blue raspberry gelatin and one cup of granulated sugar.
  3. Once your water is boiled, add the hot water to your gelatin and sugar and mix until completely dissolved. 
  4. Once gelatin and sugar have dissolved you can then add the pineapple juice and ginger ale to the pitcher. Or if you are not using ginger ale this is when you would add the lemon-lime soft drink. 

There you have it, your very own witches brew mocktail recipe. Serve over some ice and enjoy your creation. 

Collage images of making witches brew.
In process images in a collage of making witches brew punch.

All About Gelatin

You may be thinking that it is a strange ingredient to add gelatin to this witches brew drink recipe but not only does it help with the color and flavor, but gelatin is also a source of protein. Who knew? 

♻️ Recipe Variations

Want to make an adult version of this recipe? Adding one cup of vodka to the punch will be a big hit. Add when you are at the stage of adding pineapple juice and ginger ale. Enjoy this Witches Brew Cocktail!

Don’t want to use ginger ale? You can use a lemon-lime soft drink instead. This will add more of a lime flavor to this punch. You could also add a splash of orange juice or grape soda for a fun mix.

Want to add some fruit to the witch’s brew? A great addition would be something like blueberries as they would really work well. 

Do you like the idea of making the witch’s brew even sweeter? Add some gummy worms or other Halloween-themed sweets to your finished mocktail. Things like lime sherbet could also be a great option. You could also add some Halloween sprinkles on top of the punch if you wish.

Want to add a touch of hocus pocus to your witch’s brew? If you want a party tip then add a little dry ice to add a bit of spooky fun to this fun party drink.

💡 Tips & Tricks

  • Make sure the sugar and gelatin are completely dissolved before adding any of the other ingredients. 
  • If you are wanting to serve this Witches Brew in a large cauldron, and why wouldn’t you, make sure you use one that doesn’t have holes in the bottom. However, the witch’s brew also looks fantastic served in a large bowl as well as a centerpiece.
Looking down on jars of Witches Brew with cauldron.

Storage

This is a great recipe to make ahead of time and will store perfectly in the refrigerator. Like with many fun Halloween drinks and food they may be specifically for a party. After some time, you may notice the carbonation diminishing but it is still safe to drink and delicious. Add leftovers to a sealed mason jar or airtight container for up to five days. 

? FAQ

Can you make this witches’ brew recipe be made ahead of time?

Yes, it can be. Just get to the stage just before serving and store it in the refrigerator. Don’t add the ice until you are ready to serve. 

Can this be made with sparkling water or club soda instead of ginger ale or a lemon-lime soft drink?

We don’t see why you couldn’t use sparkling water that you could pick up at your local store for this Witches Brew Drink. However, the ginger ale or lemon-lime soft drink alternative does add to the flavor of the kid-friendly witches brew recipe. 

Other Cocktail Delicious recipes 

Cupids Cocktail This is a lovely Valentine’s inspired cocktail that can be made kid-friendly. 

Winter wonderland drink The perfect drink for kids to enjoy during the holiday season. 

Easy grinch cocktail One just for the adults flavored with apple vodka. Ideal for a Christmas party. 

Purple Rain Drink A wonderful flavored cocktail that could easily be adapted for a spooky spectacle. This one is just for adults. 

Green Halloween cocktail A delectable green punch that has a flavor of lime juice and is one for the adults.

Close up of a Witches Brew in a jar with a handle.

Easy Witches Brew Punch Recipe

Mason Jar Recipe
Make this fun Witches Brew Punch for all your Halloween parties! It's kid-friendly and super tasty for both kids and adults. Yummy Witches Brew recipe.
Prep Time 10 mins
Cook Time 5 mins
Total Time 15 mins
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Servings 10 servings

Equipment

Ingredients
  

  • 1 3oz package blue raspberry gelatin
  • 1 cup granulated sugar
  • 2 cups boiling water
  • 2 cups chilled pineapple juice
  • 2 cups bottle chilled ginger ale or lemon-lime soft drink

Instructions
 

  • Get your large stock pot and boil 2 cups of water. Or you could use your tea kettle for this.
  • Next up, get a pitcher and add the blue raspberry gelatin and one cup of granulated sugar.
  • Once your water is boiled, add the hot water to your gelatin and sugar and mix until completely dissolved.
  • Once gelatin and sugar have dissolved you can then add the pineapple juice and ginger ale to the pitcher. Or if you are not using ginger ale this is when you would add the lemon-lime soft drink.

Notes

  • Make sure the sugar and gelatin are completely dissolved before adding any of the other ingredients. 
  • If you are wanting to serve this Witches Brew in a large cauldron, and why wouldn’t you, make sure you use one that doesn’t have holes in the bottom. However, the witch’s brew also looks fantastic served in a large bowl as well as a centerpiece.
Keyword Witches Brew Punch
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Make sure to follow us on Instagram and Pinterest to keep up with all our new recipes. Tag us if you make the recipe on IG or share your thoughts by commenting on the pin on Pinterest.

Keep On Sippin’ On Something Sweet

Pin It For Later

Pin image of the Witches Brew Punch in a jar with a lit up cauldron.
Recipe Rating